Investors in Ripple’s XRP Rely on SEC Guidance To Claim It Was An ‘Unregistered Security’

September 27, 2019 | Digital Assets

Investors amended their complaint in a May 2018 lawsuit regarding the XRP cryptocurrency, relying on SEC’s guidance on digital assets.

The SEC’s Framework for “Investment Contract” Analysis of Digital Assets has given a group of plaintiffs more power to their elbow in a May 2018 lawsuit regarding the XRP cryptocurrency.

The investors have further amended their complaint based on the Framework. The amended complaint reinforces their contention that they were illegally sold XRP, a digital cryptocurrency, as an unregistered security.

XRP cryptocurrency is a security

The May 2018 lawsuit set out to prove that XRP was a security, no less.

It relied on the Howey decision in the U.S. Supreme Court and associated case law to prove the existence of an “investment contract,” via the following tests:

  1. Investment of money
  2. In a common enterprise
  3. With a reasonable expectation of profits
  4. Derived from the efforts of others (e.g., a promoter or other third party).

Amended filing

The plaintiffs have now dissected the SEC’s Framework and offered a point-by-point analysis to bolster their claim against Ripple that its sales of XRP cryptocurrency constituted illegal sales of unregistered securities.

The comparison, therefore, maps the relevant section of the Framework to the plaintiffs’ allegations to prove that XRP qualified as a “security.”

Economic reality

Meanwhile, the plaintiffs also supported their arguments regarding “the economic reality of the transaction,” a test detailed in Para II (3) of the Framework.

Further, a seven-element analysis of economic reality checked all of them as ‘No.’

[While none are determinative, the more these elements are true for a given digital asset, the less likely it is to satisfy the Howey test (i.e., less likely to fall under the SEC definition of an “investment contract.”]

Finally, investor Ryan Coffey filed the suit in May 2018 seeking class-action status against Ripple Labs, subsidiary XRP II, CEO Brad Garlinghouse and other individuals. However, investors Vladi Zakinov, Avner Greenwald and David Oconer filed similar suits later. They claimed XRP qualifies as a security.

Free Industry News

Subscribe to our free newsletter for updates and news about alternatives investments.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Alt Insights

January 16, 2020

ESG: Lately-turned Tesla Bull Jim Cramer Adds Fink To The Mix

ESG: Lately-turned Tesla Bull Jim Cramer Adds Fink To The Mix
Shape

Latest Alternative Investment News

Digital Assets: The Digital Dollar Foundation and Accenture Launch the Digital Dollar Project
January 17, 2020     Digital Assets, News

J. Christopher Giancarlo, former Chair of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), along with Charles Giancarlo and Daniel Gorfine, have joined hands with Accenture on the digital dollar, or US…

Digital Assets: In Reforms Push, China Mulling Rules for New Digital Banks, Including by Foreigners
January 17, 2020     Digital Assets, Regulations

China is working on guidelines for the establishment of online-only banks. Chinese regulators are pushing for the establishment of new, 100% digital banks to reduce risk in the country’s financial…

ESG: Cerulli Report Says 2020 To Be “Pivotal” For Retail ESG Investing
January 17, 2020     ESG and Sustainability, Special Reports

New regulations, products, and money will make 2020 a banner year for ESG in Europe Sustainable and responsible investing around the themes of Environment-Social-Governance (ESG) will come into its own…

The DailyAlts Playbook: Short Strategies for Tesla and Apple, where Ken Griffin was on Wednesday, Kyle Bass’ Hong Kong Worries, and the GAO’s Statement on Donald Trump
January 17, 2020     Investments, News, The DailyAlts Playbook

Today, the DailyAlts Playbook talks about short strategies for Tesla and Apple,  where Ken Griffin was on Wednesday, Kyle Bass’ Hong Kong worries, and the GAO’s statement on Donald Trump.