NBER: Beware Bond Mutual Funds and Their Reported Holdings

The agency says that 30% of bond mutual funds carry more risk than advertised

The National Bureau of Economic Research issued a stark warning about bond mutual funds and risk. In a new report, NBER says that at least 30% of bond mutual funds hold riskier assets than what Morningstar reports. The agency released this warning in a report titled “Don’t Take Their Word For It: The Misclassification of Bond Mutual Funds.”

The new study says that these funds have exposed investors thanks to a “large information chasm.”

“Many funds report more investment-grade assets than are actually held in their portfolios, making these funds appear significantly less risky,” the authors write.

“This results in pervasive misclassifications across the universe of US fixed income mutual funds by Morningstar, who relies on these reported holdings. The problem is widespread- resulting in about 30% of funds being misclassified with safer profiles, when compared against their actual, publicly reported holdings. “Misclassified funds” – i.e., those that hold risky bonds, but claim to hold safer bonds– outperform the actual low-risk funds in their peer groups. “Misclassified funds” therefore receive higher Morningstar Ratings (significantly more Morningstar Stars) and higher investor flows due to this perceived outperformance.”

National Bureau of Economic Research on Bond Funds

The National Bureau of Economic Research highlights problems at the fund family level.

“Misreporting is stronger following several quarters of large negative returns, and it is strong at the fund family level,” the authors state. “We report those families that have the highest percentage of misreported funds in the sample.

The NBER team – led by Huaizhi Chen – said that the misreporting has been “persistent, widespread, and appears strategic – casting misreported funds in a significantly more positive position than in actuality.”

The team highlights Morningstart’s reliance on self-reported summary data. This data is used to build risk classifications and register fund ratings referred to as “Morningstar Stars.”

“Now this would be no issue if funds were truthfully passing on a realistic view of the fund’s actual holdings to Morningstar,” the authors note. “Unfortunately, we know that’s not the case. We provide robust and systematic evidence that funds on average report significantly safer portfolios than they actually (verifiably) hold.”

Related: EY Report Talks Dealmaking in the Year Ahead

Free Industry News

Subscribe to our free newsletter for updates and news about alternatives investments.


Alt Insights

November 20, 2019

Prison For the Man Who Tried to Scam The Mooch

Prison For the Man Who Tried to Scam The Mooch

Latest Alternative Investment News

Activist Carl Icahn Is Shorting Mall Owners – Should You?
November 20, 2019     Investments, Latest News, News, Real Estate

Activist Carl Icahn has taken another big bet against a sector. This time, the hedge fund manager is targeting mall operators. Icahn could earn $400 million or more if mall…

Here’s What’s in the Apollo Management 13-F
November 20, 2019     Investments, News, Private Equity

The Apollo Management 13-F reveals what the private equity and alternative investment firm bought and sold in the third quarter. While we cannot see or benefit from their private holdings,…

Fidelity Digital Assets Secures New York State License

Fidelity Digital Assets received a license from the New York State Department of Financial Services. The state regulator provided permission for the crypto-arm of Fidelity Investments to offer new services….

Prison For the Man Who Tried to Scam The Mooch
November 20, 2019     Headlines, Hedge Funds, Investments, News

Premium Point Investments trader receives 40 months in prison for a mismarking scheme. Anthony Scaramucci has received justice from the firm that caused Skybridge Capital about a $79 million loss….